November 27th: Vayishlach
THIS WEEK IN THE TORAH
Rabbi David E. Ostrich
Here we are again at Vayishlach, and as we read about the assault against Dina and her brothers’ response, the relevance remains tragically current. How are we to respond to violence?
Genesis 34 tells us how Dinah, the lone daughter among Jacob’s twelve children, “went out to visit the daughters of the land.” Her family is sojourning near Shechem (now Nablus), a town north of present-day Jerusalem, and while out, she is assaulted by Shechem, son of the local leader. He “took her and lay with her by force.” In the aftermath, Shechem claims that he loves Dinah and wants to marry her. Dinah’s brothers—especially two of her full-brothers, “were distressed and very angry, because he had committed an outrage in Israel by lying with Jacob’s daughter—a thing not to be done.”
Hamor, the local chieftain and father of Shechem, approaches Dinah’s family with an offer of marriage—not only between Dinah and Shechem but also between many members of the two tribes. Jacob’s sons agree to this plan, but with a condition. All the men in Shechem’s tribe must be circumcised. Shechem is apparently quite well-liked because all the men agree and go through the surgery. Then, “on the third day, when they were in pain, Simeon and Levi…took each his sword, came upon the city unmolested, and slew all the males. They put Hamor and his son Shechem to the sword, and took Dinah out of Shechem’s house…”
Jacob is aghast and worried that this violence will make their family “odious” among the locals and invoke hostility and destruction, but Simeon and Levi are more concerned about being perceived as weak. They respond, “Should our sister be treated like a whore?”—which sounds to me like the modern, The best defense is a strong and merciless offence. When the surrounding tribes see how we respond to this outrage, they will think twice about “messing with us” again.
I have, for some sixty years, been hearing an almost identical argument about how Israel should best deal with its Arab neighbors.
(1) Some say that Arabs are nice people just like us, and if we just treat them nicely, they’ll be nice back.
(2) Others say that Arab culture sees kindness as weakness—a weakness that invites aggression. Better to be very tough with Arabs and keep them a little frightened of Jews.
In the face of today’s raging hostility in the Arab and Muslim world, how can Israel and world Jewry best defend ourselves. We are clearly in danger; what do we do?
Among those who are more-or-less supportive of Israel, there has recently been a curious attempt to separate Benjamin Netanyahu from Israel, and they say things like, “I’m not against Israel; I’m just against Netanyahu.” The notion seems to be that another leader will lead Israel in a “nicer” way and not invoke so much hostility. I wonder about this. There are certainly things about the current Netanyahu coalition that need to be changed, but I doubt that any improvement will make the haters of Zion change their minds.
Whoever the new Prime Minister turns out to be, there is little chance that he will, “beat their swords into plowshares and their spears into pruning hooks” (Micah 4). Based on the results of Israel’s recent election, the new Prime Minister will be a vigorous military defender of Israel. Netanyahu’s Likud Party got 27 seats but was closely followed by former general Gadi Eisenkot’s Yashar Party with 21 seats. Add to these the smaller parties like Yachad/Together headed by former general Naftali Bennett (12 seats) and Israel Beiteinu headed by secular nationalist Avigdor Lieberman (7 seats), and you begin to see that most Israelis want a strong and assertive military. Whether or not these parties can work together is more a reflection of personalities and strategic and internal political issues that escape most non-Israeli news reports. Perhaps there are ways for the military to do better, but any notion of Israel rolling over and giving up is remarkably unrealistic. Whether led by Netanyahu or another, Israel is going to continue defending itself—and those who wish for Israel’s destruction will not be any happier.
Lest we try to turn our Israeli cousins into “cases” who do not understand what is in their best interests, perhaps we can be informed by their thinking and their plight. They are scared to death of the Arab/Muslim threat, and they see the conflict as a life-or-death war. They are not persuaded by the anti-Israel and anti-Jewish marches, demonstrations, boycotts, and speeches. In fact, they see them as proof of the Arab/Muslim existential threat, and the worldwide campaign against Israel and Jews reinforces their belief that Israeli weakness will lead to destruction. Israel is a democracy full of many different opinions and philosophies, but the clear consensus is that a strong defense is necessary in a hostile world.
Our Israeli cousins also recall that the October 7th attack was an invasion from an Arab country—one ruled by Palestinians since 2005. Israelis understand that “from the River to the Sea” means marching millions of Jews “into the sea”—or at least sending them packing from their homes and their land. And Israelis remember the premise of Theodor Herzl’s Zionist theory: that the world is hostile to Jews and will never fully accept us. For many Israelis, the only hope is in going along with the nationalistic thinking of the 19th Century and focusing on our own Jewish nationalism and our ancestral homeland and refuge, Eretz Yisrael.
Some Jews are like Jacob and worry about appearing “odious” to others, but many other Jews are in the camp of Simeon and Levi. They do not want to appear weak—and they want others to be wary of “messing” with Israel. As the Psalmist hopes:
“Adonai oz l’amo yiten; Adonai yivarech et amo vashalom.
May the Lord give strength to our people; may the Lord bless our people with peace.” (29.11)
